Do I pay for my custom cake online or in-store? Festival Foods September 28, 2020 10:56 Updated Follow You will pay in-store at the register after you pick up your cake from the Bakery Department. Related articles Cake Order How do I upload a photo? How do I edit or cancel my online cake order? How do I know when my cake is ready for pick up? Mobile Text Club Comments 0 comments Article is closed for comments.